Case in point, IKEA will happily sell you a very well built 20W power supply that provides 5, 9, 12, or 15V for less than $5 here in Canada, and you can get a similar price from legitimate Asian distributors, even when buying in limited quantities. If you're working on a small-batch electronic product, that's a boon to your BOM; if you had to go out and source a dedicated barrel-jack PSU with the same capabilities, it'd cost much more, and you don't know what kind of quality you'd be getting.
Where the standard really falls on its face, IMO, is in its opacity. You can get a chip that does the PD negotiation for pennies, but there is no way to inspect the protocol without shelling out thousands for a dedicated analyzer, so when things don't work, it's really hard to troubleshoot the reason.
(Disclaimer: I'm working on an open-source protocol analyzer, so this probably colours my view on the matter a little.)
This is a non issue, IMO. Does it depend on the electronics being designed correctly? Sure, but that’s the case for all electronics, and most devices probably build on some widely-available standardized control boards from 3rd parties.
As a user, I’m sooo happy that I can bring a portable battery and a wall charger, and both can recharge every single one of my portable devices. From gaming handhelds to large, powerful laptops, to wireless earbuds, to cameras, to smart watches, to flashlights. All with very different power requirements.