Hacker News Reader

Were those rhetorical questions?

Not sure where you derived them, but my only point was: usually when enough outraged people are outraged someone/some company gives in. Unfortunate, but true. Personally, I think it's a great idea.

When was the last time a parent actually talked to their child instead of complaining about it being someonelse's problem?

I'm pretty sure we only get to hear the ones that complain.

Yeah, I wasn't aware if I typed in xxx at Google they now wait 5 seconds and send me to a porn site automatically.

They do if you're feeling lucky.

User looks up xxx on Justin.tv for xxx on Justin.tv

User looks up xxx on Google for xxx

The intent is different and the auto-redirect, even at 5 seconds, is troubling.

The intent, when searching for porn on Justin.tv, is presumably to find "xxx" "channels". Being redirected to porn is exactly what the user desires, since that's what he searched for.