Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by pclowes | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

pclowes·

Additionally any college grad that:

1. Takes out six figures of loans for a degree in a field with no hope of commensurate income

2. Pays minimum payments below interest

3. Whines on social media that after X years of not even covering the interest payment they now owe more than ever

Should:

1. Lose both their college and HS degrees. They clearly dont understand HS math.

2. Their college’s accreditation should be investigated

3. Same with their HS

View on HN

So your solution for the system failing a person is to punish the person but reward the powerful people engaged in the bad behavior. The ones who brainwashed the kids into thinking that this is what they're supposed to do.

No, the people giving degrees that say a person can do basic math when the person can’t do math should not be able to give out degrees anymore.

Similarly, the person with the credential that says they can do basic math that cannot do basic math should not have the credential.

People have agency. The system didn't fail a person. That framing completely ignores their actions. Especially for paying so little on their loans and complaining about it. 18 year olds can vote. If we trust them with that, surely they can be responsible for their own choices.

Moreover, they said the accreditation of both institutions should be investigated.

Not so. The consideration should include the fact that when a child has been spawn camped by school, family and society at large to implant the idea that tertiary education is required to participate in society and without a degree one amounts to nothing, as is often the case, then it indeed is a failure of systematic nature and it would be not fair to put the blame on the now young adult's shoulders alone.

You’re an obnoxious, pretentious prick

Reply on news.ycombinator.com