Hacker News Reader

Comment by olivierestsage | Hacker News Reader

Is there any reasonably practical way to play a "restricted" version of MtG with physical cards and a somewhat stable ruleset, reminiscent of what play was like in the late 90s (as I remember it)? I like what's being proposed here, but I don't have access to old cards.

I'm not averse to buying new cards, I just don't want to be on an infinite treadmill of buying new cards and learning new rules forever, it's just not fun in my opinion

View on HN

If you want to restrict yourself to cards printed before a certain date, why not ask your play group to do just that? If you need more inspiration, there are unofficial formats like 93-94, Old Frame Vintage, Premodern, etc.

ETA: I don't know what gameplay is like as you remember it, but you might be interested in Pauper, especially if you are looking for a more official format. A good number of old school cards are relevant in that format, and these cards won't rotate out. Sometimes new cards enter the meta, but because you're limited to commons, it's not expensive. You also can just keep a deck around for a while. It's ok if you're not at the cutting edge of the meta...

You should look into "cube" formats and cube drafts. You might be able to go to your local LGS (gaming store) to set up a cube draft. If it's a cube that uses vintage cards you can usually print proxies for the ultra expensive cards

Yes: Premodern and Legacy. Personally I like Modern and don't mind having things shaken up fairly regularly, but if you want more stability play Legacy and if you want ultimate stability with no new cards ever, play Premodern.

Just use proxies. There is nothing stopping someone from just making an entire deck of proxies.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com