Hacker News Reader

Comment by mikey_p | Hacker News Reader

The web still has other protocols on top of it, like RSS. Just because the "web" exists doesn't mean that solves every problem.

Also OAuth only handles auth and permissions and doesn't do anything for provided federated views of disparate data sources.

Also this isn't about identity either, you're really misunderstanding what this is about.

View on HN

You're right. RSS builds on top of the web. ATProto does not. I'd say RSS is a resource format / content type, not a communications protocol. A resource format intended for syndicating updates – exactly what ATProto and ActivityPub do (but decided to invent new formats instead of extending RSS/Atom. JSON all the things!).

It is very much about identity. To use tangled you need to use ATProto and authenticate using ATProto – rather than using the existing open standard for authentication used by pretty much everyone at this point (missed opportunity to login to Tangled using GitHub). What's crazy is people still use the web to interact with tangled anyway.

That's like saying that DAV doesn't build on HTTP.

And just because an existing standard exists does not forgo the creation of other standards that incorporate other features. I don't know how to build a social graph based on OAuth logins, but this would be fairly easy with ATProto.|

Genuinely don't know why you are even using HTTP when Telnet and Gopher are right there...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com