Hacker News Reader

It's really hard to push DDR5 past 6000MT/s on 4+ DIMMs it seems.

I had to get everything top spec to fit 4 channels of 6000MT/s on my 9950x (asus proArt motherboard and the top tier trident neo RAM sticks) -- otherwise it's reportedly unstable.

View on HN

9950X is dual channel, running 4 DIMMs runs them interleaved, with two DIMMs sharing one physical connection, impacting signal integrity severely. AFAIK this has gotten worse with DDR5 to the point that it's generally recommended to avoid 4 DIMMs unless you really can't get enough RAM otherwise. For maximum bandwidth you need to avoid interleaving.

Strix Halo simply has more memory controllers. Threadrippers are also quad channel, and should be able to run 4 DIMMs at rated speeds, but the cheapest Zen 5 Threadripper seems to be almost double the price of a 9950X3D.

And I presume that doubled price is before you look at the workstation class motherboards, which also tend to be much more expensive.

Thanks for the info on the hardware quirks, useful to know!

We seem to be arriving at a cambrian explosion of viable hardware these days between ARM and x86, soldered vs DIMM, etc.

It's refreshing coming from 20 years of x86 being all that matters.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com