Hacker News Reader

Comment by bulbar | Hacker News Reader

[flagged]

Aside from the fact that the Iranian Regime never said that...why exactly should westerners care about the fate of Israel?

I know they think they are special, but to me they are just another West Asian country. I have zero reason to support them over Yemen, Lebanon, Iran, or any other state. Arguably I have more reason to resent them, considering how much money and blood we have spent furthering their cause and how ungrateful they are in return.

No Mullah ever called me "goy".

And you know what's the worst thing? I don't know if its my sample bias, but I see very rarely Israelis complaining about actual "gas the kikes white power" hateful antisemite filth which have actually risen in quantity quite a lot recently. The only people who get smeared with the antisemite label are people who hundreds of times even to the point of most normal people would stop seeing the distinction between jews and Israeli actions but they still clarify the various ways they aren't talking about jewish people or judaism as a religion but Israeli governments actions, and perfectly reasonable people like the Irish get labelled as "extreme antisemites". You know what signal this sends? If repeatedly clarifying the difference between jews in general and criminal actions of Israel gets the label of antisemite and actual blood and soil neo nazis get ignored then perhaps people should become actual loud and proud antisemites, this is what Israelis mindset signals to people.

I have not seen a single prominent anti-semite on X talk about Jews in a more vile way than Randy Fine - a US representative - talks about Arabs.

The only "greatest ally" that sold secrets to china, attacked american ships and refused to apologize, has characters like Pollard as heroes, jailed and tortured the man who exposed their illegal theft of nuclear weapons tech from South Africa, ....

> attacked american ships

Ship, not ships. The USS liberty accident 58 years ago was the only instance.

> refused to apologize

Israel apologized the same day of the incident. They also paid $13m in reparations (much more if we adjust for inflation).

> their illegal theft of nuclear weapons tech from South Africa

There was no theft from South Africa. His conviction was for leaking info about the Israeli program.

>Israel apologized the same day of the incident. They also paid $13m in reparations (much more if we adjust for inflation).

That's the "public" view yes. Many survivors disagree of course.

The entity who committed theft was Israel not Mordechai, however I reread it and it looks like it was a secret collaboration with South Africa not theft. But the main point is, why should you listen to whining about Iran having nukes from a country that blatantly lies about its own nukes and refuses to let its nukes be inspected? Iran is a much more responsible party clearly when it comes to the nuclear department.

It's also very well known that Israel secretly sold western defence tech secrets to China.

You seem to have mistakenly passed over part of my message that mentioned Pollard, so have a link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Pollard

> they are just another West Asian country

They're not, they're just a temporary European colony that cannot survive without constant pouring of resources from the collective West. Like the crusader states of the 11th and 12th century. It's not a real country.

I do not support the ethnic cleansing of Jews from Palestine any more than I support the current Jewish ethnic cleansing of Arabs in Palestine. Both groups want to force the other into the western world and I reject both.

No ethnic cleansing will be required, and the dissolution of apartheid South Africa tells us how things will play out. Once the state is degraded enough, they will largely all emigrate on their own since the jewish supremacy that is currently in full swing will be no longer. They will not want to live in a state where others have equal rights. The few who don't mind it will remain and live on with the majority that currently enjoys little to no rights.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com