Comment by mft_ | Hacker News Reader

Comment by mft_ | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

(I’ve posted this before on HN but it’s worth repeating)

I’m an CAD hobbyist, and I’ve tried to work with FreeCAD multiple times over past years, always failing….

…until I saw this video and learned about version 1.1:

https://youtu.be/VEfNRST_3x8

FreeCAD is now in the same ballpark of capability and usability as Solidworks. It can still be a bit clunky and frustrating sometimes, but then so can most CAD programs, in their own ways.

Side note: the creator of the video above also has a video on optimising the FreeCAD interface. (There are some frustrations related to the interface generally, and this would seem to be a low hanging fruit for the FreeCAD team to address.)

In terms of ux as a beginner what made me able to learn effectively was a command palette add-on (outlined here)[0].

It really sped up learning for me. (because I'd know what the thing I wanted was called, but couldn't find them, and having to google and search before every click is... not fun)

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47088675

Awesome, thanks for repeating.

I have, like, an old married couple relationship with SolidWorks. Stockholm syndrome may be more accurate. It shaped how I think, it aggravates me as only a long-time companion could, but overall I'm fond of it.

It gives me hope that others have made the switch. I've wanted to love FreeCAD for a long time, too.

I think we’re in a similar place. I invested enough time over several years to understand the quirks and avoid the frustrations of a certain CAD package (allegedly, possibly Solidworks).

And it’s now helpful to remind myself, each time I find FreeCAD difficult or clunky, of all of those times that Solidworks was also, just in different ways. Or the time that Fusion lost a whole part of a model. Or the lack of a parametric history in lots of other competitors. Or the awfulness of trying to refer to specific parts of a model in progress of OpenSCAD. And so on…

Reply on news.ycombinator.com