Hacker News Reader

Comment by zozbot234 | Hacker News Reader

The borrow checker involves documenting the ownership of data throughout the program. That's what people are calling "overly verbose" and saying it "makes comprehensive large-scale refactoring impractical" as an argument against Rust. (And no it doesn't, it's just keeping you honest about what the refactor truly involves.)

View on HN

The annoying experience with the borrow checker is when following the compiler errors after making a change until you hit a fundamental ownership problem a few levels away from the original change that precludes the change (like ending up with a self referencial borrow). This can bite even experienced developers, depending on how many layers of indirection there are (and sometimes the change that would be adding a single Rc or Cell in a field isn't applicable because it happens in a library you don't control). I do still prefer hitting that wall than having it compile and end up with rare incorrect runtime behaviour (with any luck, a segfault), but it is more annoying than "it just works because the GC dealt with it for me".

There are also limits to what the borrow checker is capable of verifying. There will always be programs which are valid under the rules the borrow checker is enforcing, but the borrow checker rejects.

It's kinda annoying when you run into those. I think I've also ran into a situation where the borrow checker itself wasn't the issue, but rather the way references were created in a pattern match causing the borrow checker to reject the program. That was also annoying.

Polonius hopefully arrives next year and reduces the burden here further. Partial field borrows would be huge so that something like obj.set_bar(obj.foo()) would work.

Given the troubles with shipping Polonius, I imagine that there isn't much more room for improvements in "pure borrow checking" after Polonius, though more precise ways to borrow should improve ergonomics a lot more. You mentioned borrowing just the field; I think self-referential borrows are another.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com