Hacker News Reader

I don't think it'd be illegal for anyone.

The (theoretical) scenario is: There is a website (example.com) that publishes the correct credentials, and tells users to go to example.com/authenticate and put those there.

At no point is a user (or bot) bypassing anything that was meant to stop them, they're following what the website is telling them publicly.

View on HN

I think this analysis is correct. The part you're missing from my comment is "at scale", which means trying to apply this scraping technique to other sites. As a contract security engineer I've found all kinds of accidentally leaked credentials; knowing if a set of credentials is accidentally leaked or are being intentionally disclosed to the public feels like a human-in-the-loop kind of thing. Getting it wrong, especially when automated at scale, is the context the bot writer needs to consider.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com