Hacker News Reader

Comment by blks | Hacker News Reader

ICE actively targets and arrests people who are legally staying in the US as well, detaining them for weeks without due process.

View on HN

What exactly is your evidence for this claim?

What do you consider to be their basis for such targeting, and what is your evidence for that claim?

Off the top of my head, Kilmar Abrego Garcia had a judicial stay against exportation and the administration said his deportation was an error, but he spent weeks in an El Salvadoran prison. And there was the Korean battery factory workers in Georgia.

There were also more cases in the district court record that led to the Kavanaugh Stops decision: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2025/10/scotus-analysis-...

There have been so many cases documented so thoroughly. All you have to do is believe that it's not impossible and the reporting does the rest.

How does that demonstrate targeting people whose presence is legal?

What a weird attempt at semantics. They "target" people based on skin color/appearance/attitude/language, completely ignoring the legalities.

Thats the issue.

It is not semantics. They are not doing any such "targeting"; they are using this information among other factors, in a context where it objectively is rational to use that information, and it has already been found in court (hence "Kavanaugh Stops decision") that this is lawful. (Granted, this is only a stay against an injunction.) I gave details at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45581400 .

It demonstrates carelessness in only targeting people whose presence is illegal, with legal residents being collateral damage.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com