Woah buddy, I worked with Andy for years and this is not my experience. Moving a large product like S3 around is really, really difficult, and I've always thought highly of Andy's ability to: (a) predict where he thought the product should go, (b) come up with novel ways of getting there, and (c) trimming down the product to get something in the hands of customers.
Also, did you create this account for the express purpose of bashing Andy? That's not cool.