Hacker News Reader

I have YT Premium and if Google bans yt-dlp, I will cancel my subscription. I pay them not to do that.

you show them who’s boss, premium user

Seems quite naive to think they'd be affected in any way by the tiny intersection of users that are both yt-dlp users and premium subscribers boycotting them...

I think it is not about making a change, it is putting money where your mouth is.

To buy premium to support creators.

Once yt becomes hostile the deal between me and yt is off.

If every user of yt-dlp did as I do, then it would have exactly the effect that it needs to have. If yt-dlp is used by a small minority of users, why would Google be antagonistic to it? And if it's used by sizeable portion of users, then they would care.

> If yt-dlp is used by a small minority of users, why would Google be antagonistic to it?

The concern is likely that if they let it become too easy the small minority becomes a large majority and the ad business becomes unsustainable.

Consider the ease and adoption of newsgroups in the early 90s vs Napster/Limewire later and the effect that had on revenues.

Primarily because they contractually promised the music industry they'd do everything they can to prevent tools that allow the downloading of copyrighted music from the service.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com