Hacker News Reader

Comment by rubenbe | Hacker News Reader

Nice idea!

I do notice quite some people focus the autodiscovery part where for me that's less of an issue (I do agree it would be VERY nice). The OpenWISP configuration on each AP is limited to: set IP address of controller & shared secret and click OK. The rest is all magically done for you by the controller.

I do like the 304 idea, in practice it uses the same conceptual idea as the OpenWISP system: check if the MD5 (instead of SHA1) for the current config and the controller config are still identical and download and apply if not.

An important reason I why chose the OpenWISP is that they "just work", are well tested and included in the OpenWRT package list. My main goal is to keep the OpenSOHO project as small as possible ;)

View on HN

I've been weighing the pros/cons of using OpenWISP. I considered using DHCP to distribute the controller IP and shared secret.

For now, I like reasoning about /etc config files. I'm more familiar with those than OpenWISP. Adopting an abstraction like that offers some portability and possibly future proofing. But that is just the config format and how it is applied though really.

I think once the router is setup, most SOHO users only ever have to add/replace (provision) APs and manage the WiFi settings. I want to make that kind of provisioning and management automatic. Making the APs as stateless as possible - kind of like a Chromebook. The agent will only have basic dependencies (lua, curl, tar).

For this to really work it'll probably have to grow to support VLAN-backed SSIDs and wireless backhaul links. Wireless links would probably need to be wired for their first time setup. But I'd be happy even if it just solved managing my own APs and SSIDs.

OpenSOHO and OpenWisp do both send parts of /etc/config files to the AP.

While we're discussing: someone did an attempt in the OpenSOHO discussions to have a freshly flashed AP register automatically with OpenSOHO:

https://github.com/rubenbe/opensoho/discussions/1#discussion...

The Openwisp agents running on the AP are surprisingly lightweight (they do use Lua, tar, curl and a bit of shell scripting)

VLAN backed SSIDs are one of main reason I started OpenSOHO (although support is not there yet) I don't want to log into each AP to set it up manually. I do have a wired back haul, but support for wireless backhaul will probably arrive, since quite some people have one set up.

In case you would find an easy method of bootstrapping the setup via DHCP, certainly let me know! (Maybe that's easier to be discussed on GitHub)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com