Hacker News Reader

Comment by justsomejew | Hacker News Reader

Communism was quite different from nazism, whatever they tell and told you in the west. You just did not live there, and some people rewrote the history for you. Equating communism and nazism is one of the most abominable aspects of western propaganda

View on HN

They are both the same. One wants one true race society and the the other one true class society. The only way tho achieve one or the other state is by eliminating those who don't conform (Holocaust and Holodomor). It's despicable some pretend one is better then the other.

Accusing Karl Marx of what Stalin did is like saying Lincoln is guilty of Trump.

And how can you achieve a classless society without violence?

Violence on the rich is justified. Unless of course they give it up willingly.

In the view of the whole world you (probably) belong to the very rich. Does that statement apply to you? Are you willing to donate all your goods to Africa?

If everyone else does, proportionally to their means, sure!

If I have to starve myself, I don't see what would it solve…

So, no then, if it would hurt you, but you are fine hurting others for your goals.

You're the one saying that taxes and amputations are the same. I don't think you're qualified to have mature discussions.

Where am I saying that?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44866499

Where do you see a discussion about taxes? We are talking about communists killing people because they are of the wrong class and nazis killing people because they are of the wrong race.

Perhaps inside your head you were indeed talking about that. I have no way of knowing. The actual text that is written here is different.

The other side says something similar. Violence on "not my race" is justified, because they are subhumans.

You can't change race, you can change wealth.

How exactly can you change wealth? Would you lobotomize more intelligent people, perhaps knee cap athletes, break fingers of musicians?

Wealth isn't a part of one's body… redistributing wealth is not the same as mutilating people. This comparison is insane.

I don't know about you, but for me my mind is my wealth. For an athlete their body is and so on. This is the basis for building all additional wealth.

Seeing your comments, if your mind is your wealth, you could really use some wealth redistribution because you got the short end of the stick :)

More seriously, redefining meanings of all the words is not conductive of a useful discussion. Feel free to consult a dictionary when you're in doubt about the meaning of extremely common words.

No need to be vile, I hope you are ok.

Let me remind you that you're the one who introduced maiming people in a discussion about taxes…

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44866499

I have not mentioned or discussed taxes in this thread about equating communism and nazism.

Equating communism and nazism is wrong. Why not equate capitalism and nazism since the 2nd emerged to protect the 1st?

Ah yes, because of your dishonesty.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com