fair challenge to their proposed solution, but it doesn't negate the security premise does it? what do you think is a good alternative?
Profit driven mining companies are honestly kind of not a very good force and push for lots of weird scams to encourage mining like memecoins on BTC or "dog pictures", and also regularly mine just pump and dump alts (including the biggest BTC miners).
Mining should just be as distributed as possible and integrated into stranded power likely generating a small if any profit.