Hacker News Reader

I havent read the article, but why dont they just put it behind a free login with bandwidth restrictions per day or something?

View on HN

You want images only be available to users with a Wikipedia login? This would mean by far most people would no longer see images in Wikipedia articles.

No, I am saying what a lot of other people are. Force bots into API access, which can then be authenticated and restricted by bandwidth or calls per day. Then block bot access to html pages. Nobody looses their images, and bots are limited in stealing bandwidth.

Have you actually tried blocking these scraper bots? The whole problem is that if you do, they start impersonating normal browsers from residential IPs instead. They actively evade countermeasures.

Isnt everything measures and countermeasures though?

As far as I am aware there is no such thing as a silver bullet anywhere when it comes to security.

Its like moving your SSH port from port 22 to some other random one. Will it stop advanced scripts from scanning your server and finding it? No, but it sure as hell will cut down the noise of unsophisticated connections which means you can focus on the more tough ones.

Finally, a use for CFAA?

OK, but what's the downside?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com