The best option might be have a branded checkout using Stripe, and an option to pay with PayPal for those who maintain PayPal accounts.
I've had a lot of people ask about integrating other payment platforms into Pay Pad. I'd love to build Pay Pad in a way that was platform agnostic. Just choose your payment provider/gateway and you're off.
We'll see what happens. If enough people want it, I'll do it I'm sure.
I can't say for sure how many people would not have paid only given one of those options, but I'm sure it's a non trivial number.