Hacker News Reader

Comment by rayiner | Hacker News Reader

[flagged]

How do you know that the "overwhelming majority" are "bad people who prey on others" without a functional judicial system to prove it?

As the number of incarcerated grows from 2% to 5% to consolidate Bukele's power, what recourse will anyone have outside the party elite?

The pattern of strongman politicians, indefinite emergency measures, and erosion of liberties to manifest full bore dictatorship has repeated over and over and over again in the 20th and 21st centuries — and you still can't see it happening? You may enjoy it now, but consider this the honeymoon phase: it only gets worse from here on out.

> How do you know that the "overwhelming majority" are "bad people who prey on others" without a functional judicial system to prove it?

You think the murder rate went down by two orders of magnitude by locking up good, innocent people?

If there are 10,000 murderers out there and you lock up most of them along with 20,000 innocent people, you get the same result. (Bonus points if you happen to snag some annoying journalists, activists, and civil rights leaders in your dragnet, since they can push back on your power play and cast doubt on your stats.)

But you can just read the article if you don't believe me: "While polling consistently shows that Bukele is quite popular in El Salvador, surveys also show a steady increase in fear of public criticism of the government — to degrees that sometimes match the president’s approval rating. 'There’s a sector of the population that feels better, because it’s true that we perceive more security, we’re no longer afraid of the gangs. Now we’re afraid of the regime,' says Ramirez. 'We see soldiers everywhere, police everywhere, patrol cars, and they’re arresting people.'"

So if they lock up, torture (you are a gang member as you looked weird at your neighbour of 20 years who happens to be a friend of a the local police chief) and kill you and your family without any due process that's fine for the greater good? Don't think many people have that idea, probably nor do you; you just think so as it didn't happen to you yet. The overwhelming majority as you say does a lot here; where is the proof and process that it is the overwhelming majority? And that these people are not just people like you and your kids but who do not agree with the regime? According to the process/system, all people in Cambodia were guilty as well. You cannot have read any history and talk like this so I guess you never have.

It will get worse anyway; that 2% will rise and that gov will never go away, killing everyone who opposes them. History shows this every time.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com