Hacker News Reader

Comment by almostgotcaught | Hacker News Reader

Of course there are - an unlimited metro card is $132. the person you're responding to is nuts - no one that commutes from Bronx to downtown is paying per swipe.

View on HN

OMNI caps it, so the most you can pay is $136 per month and that is the worst case scenario. I don't think a difference of $4 is nuts.

Also Metrocards are not going to be printed anymore, I'm assuming that includes the unlimited ones, probably just shifts over to OMNY.

A 4 zone monthly ticket in London is like $300 for comparison. 6 zones is $360!

London is 3 times the size of Manhattan, Bronx, Queens and Brooklyn combined, and Zone 6 is even larger than that.

I assume an "unlimited metro card" also includes unlimited buses too?

Yes, it includes local buses. It also includes the Staten Island Railway, so it doesn't make sense to exclude an entire NYC borough from land size comparisons.

I wasn't sure and hedged on a 4 zone.

A 2 zone is $220. I think in size that's roughly comparable?

And in my experience people who mostly take the tube rarely make use of buses. They'll walk or take the tube

So assuming two rides in each working day that's still $6.42 per day

That's a bad assumption, since NYC residents tend to use the subway for non-work-related travel as well.

Assuming you don't take any non-work rides, ever.

As mentioned, you hop on a train to do anything/everything. In a single weekend you might take 10 rides.

Edit: well if you live in a part of the city that has good coverage - up in the Bronx it's not so great naturally so I wouldn't be surprised if those people didn't get as much value out of a monthly card.

But those people can still use local buses to get around on the exact same pass. So they could feasibly hit the cap anyways.

true!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com