Hacker News Reader

Comment by mnky9800n | Hacker News Reader

The milliken oil drop experiment, “winning “ the space race, mostly anything C levels will tell the board and shareholders at a shareholder meeting, the American wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, most of what Sam Altman or Elon musk has to say, this list continues.

View on HN

I think you're approaching it form very high level, when you should think about it from much lower level, i.e. success is being determined by stress/dopamine hormones or similar

The lower level seems to work eg, “Dopamine regulates decision thresholds in human reinforcement learning” https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41130-y

This article is kind of vague on that tbf: To conclude, we observed no credible evidence for a beneficial effect of L-dopa (vs. Haloperidol) on reinforcement learning in a reward context, as well as the proposed mechanistic account of an enhanced striatal prediction error response mediating this effect.

So your claim is that success stories are some kind of emergent phenomenon that comes from people chasing dopamine highs?

Is that controversial? I would say everything a human does is to feel better, and everything someone does that doesn’t make them feel better immediately is just done in the expectation of even greater pleasure later.

I don’t think the human experience can be reduced down to “if feels good is true then continue else try something else”. But I could be wrong.

Well mine can, with some tactics and strategy layered on top. If I do something I don’t like, I only do it because the payoff later makes it worth it (or at least I think it will from my current knowledge).

While humans seek “profit”.

It is important that “profit”, comes in various forms, which exchange rates are problematic to calculate (or maybe there can’t be any): not hungry, not thirsty, tastes good, not cold, feel safe, feel excited, feel righteous, feel powerful, listen to music, watch a movie, get curious, satisfy curiosity, laugh, love, sex, rock n roll.

I think it is both and this is very obvious if you read Pareto and Sapolsky.

It is more than just success too.

Most behavior we believe is some kind of rational action when it is really blind actions based on fiction or just completely random with rationalizations for the behavior after the fact.

someone once told me

> there are the facts we know and the stories we tell ourselves

and that really changed my outlook on life, the way i think about things, and basically everything else.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com