Hacker News Reader

Comment by monsieurbanana | Hacker News Reader

What he meant is that if this really happens, and LLMs replaces humans everywhere and everybody becomes unemployed, congratulations you'll be fine.

Because at that point there's 2 scenarios:

- LLMs don't need humans anymore and we're either all dead or in a matrix-like farm

- Or companies realize they can't make LLMs buy the stuff their company is selling (with what money??) so they still need people to have disposable income and they enact some kind of Universal Basic Income. You can spend your days painting or volunteering at an animal shelter

Some people are rooting for the first option though, so while it's good that you've found faith, another thing that young people are historically good at is activism.

View on HN

The scenario that is worrying is having to deal with the jagged frontier of intelligence prolonging the hurt. i.e

202X: SWE is solved

202X + Y; Y<3: All other fields solved.

In this case, I can't retrain before the second threshold but also can't idle. I just have to suffer. I'm prepared to, but it's hard to escape fleshy despair.

There's actually something you can do, that I don't think will become obsolete anytime soon.

Work on your soft skills. Join a theater club, debate club, volunteer to speak at events, ...

Not that it's easy, and certainly more difficult for some people than for others, but the truth is that soft skills already dominate engineering, and in a world where LLMs replace coders they would become more important. Companies have people at the top, and those people don't like talking to computers. That is not going to change until those people get replaced.

How about retraining for a field that would require robotics to replace?

Seems more anti-fragile.

Thats the point.

EVERYTHING is upturned. "All other things solved" includes robotics. It's a 10x everywhere.

Let's run with that number, 10x.

Say there used to be 100 jobs in some company, all executing on the vision of a small handful of people. And then this shift happens. Now there are only 10 jobs at that company, still executing on the vision of the same handful of people.

90 people are now unemployed, each with a 10x boost to whatever vision they've been neglecting since they've been too busy working at that company. Some fraction of those are going to start companies doing totally new things--things you couldn't get away with doing until you got that 10x boost--things for which there is no training data (yet).

And sure, maybe AI gets better and eats those jobs too, and we have to start chasing even more audacious dreams... but isn't that what technology is for? To handle the boring stuff so we can rethink what we're spending our time on?

Maybe there will have to be a bit of political upheaval, maybe we'll have to do something besides money, idk, but my point is that 10x everywhere opens far more doors than it shuts. I don't think this is that, but if this is that, then it's a very good thing.

Not everyone has "vision".

Most people are just drones, and that's fine, that's just not them.

So far it has seemed necessary to compel many to work in furtherance of the visions of few (otherwise there was not enough labor to make meaningful progress on anyone's vision). Probably at least a few of those you'd classify as drones aren't displaying any vision because the modern work environment has stifled it.

If AI can do the drone work, we may find more vision among us than we've come to expect.

nursing, electrician. maybe the humanoid robots will get to those soon, but we'll see

Seems inevitable once multi-modal reasoning 10x's everything. You don't even need robotics, just attach it to a headset Manna-style. All skilled blue collar work instantly deskilled. You see why I feel like I'm in a bind?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com