Hacker News Reader

Comment by ddoeth | Hacker News Reader

Maybe the difference is that you used O1 that has access to the internet, and the other users might not have.

It seems like the biggest difference is that the book is about bone people and is actually called Bone People.

A triumph of LLM literalism. It never have occurred to me that that might literally have been the title. Googling "bone people" or "bone people children's book" doesn't work; the SERPs are flooded by a different novel that won the Booker in 1986, interesting zero six-year-olds. But "bone people science fiction" does work!

I read (er, reread) it last night using the book-borrowing feature of archive.org which got them existentially sued: https://archive.org/details/bonepeople0000unse/. The mind-reading business hardly figures in the action; it's there, but marginal. The humans actually defeat the bone people by kicking one of them in the head (er, skull) and then blasting them with an air gun. Literally an air gun: it shoots air, and it turns out that air kills bone people. That was lucky!

I remain of the opinion that defeating mind-readers by keeping one's thoughts in the back of one's mind is the most interesting thing about the book, so it's not surprising that was what stuck in my mind, though not so much in the back. It's been in a trunk in the middle somewhere.

For anybody else playing the home game like I am, this is an easier read than Bruno Schulz "Street Of Crocodiles".

Later

No, that's not quite fair; you get halfway into this and it starts to be written like the Hadiths. "The Bone People do not think about a thing but what it is an evil thought." I'm always saying!

I also found it strangely written and hard to read (as an adult). At the very end, on p. 72, there is a sort of appendix for teachers which says:

  The total vocabulary of this book is 280 words, excluding proper names 
  and sound words. The 15 words in roman type should be familiar to 
  children reading on a third-grade level. The 20 words above third-grade 
  level are shown in italic type.

280 words seems rather few! That's probably why it reads like Gertrude Stein.

I’m surprised this hasn’t shown up on Reddit terrible sci-fi covers

Reply on news.ycombinator.com