Hacker News Reader

Comment by GiorgioG | Hacker News Reader

As an American born to European immigrant parents I can assure you that the grass is not always greener on the other side. All systems have problems. I say this as the parent of a child with a chronic illness (t1d) who is extremely frustrated with our health(insurance)care system.

View on HN

Not everything is better about Europe than the US, I agree (and the extent to which this is true depends on where in Europe you’re talking about - Bulgaria is not much like Switzerland).

But one of the things that I think is unambiguously better (at least in highly developed Northern and Western Europe) is the quality of democratic institutions and their responsiveness to the people’s will. In the US, it is structurally almost impossible for Congress to legislate meaningfully, so effectively no one is in charge.

As an American watching Brexit and other self-owns pouring out of the UK, I’m not completely sold on this. If our system is insane — and it is — I’d say it’s a family disorder we inherited.

I think a lot of the "insanity" we see in both the US and UK and probably elsewhere can be traced back to lies from the consolidated & ubiquitous conservative media (specifically, guys like Rupert Murdoch).

> I’d say it’s a family disorder we inherited.

A pre-existing condition? You’re not covered.

Funny, but pre-existing conditions are covered by default under the ACA.

In the US you are.

Spot on.

I saw this as an immigrant to UK from a developing country, who only recently understood what he signed up for

Ironically, Switzerland has a similar healthcare system to the US.

There are no free state-provided health services, but private health insurance is compulsory for all persons residing in Switzerland

Health insurance in the US isn't practically compulsory since SCOTUS struck down the individual mandate's fines for not having it in 2012. (It was then removed entirely from the law in 2017.)

That's not quite right. SCOTUS upheld the individual mandate fines. They didn't strike it down. [1]

Congress then set the fine to $0 in legislation passed in 2017, which went into effect in 2019. [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Federation_of_Indepen...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordable_Care_Act

Agreed, I think private healthcare is the stronger similarity.

At very least the French and Italian people would disagree (I’m French and Italian).

Seems like folks across Europe were pretty upset with the number of asylum seekers and the problems that followed their migration into Europe in the last couple of years. Their governments didn’t seem to give much of a shit and that’s led to more right-wing support.

Classic diversion. Healthcare is better in Europe. That's the topic.

Europe is a big place. Which part of Europe are you referring to? There's a huge variance in cost and quality of care between, let's say, Copenhagen and Chișinău.

And even if we look only at the wealthier EU member states, "better" depends on which metric you look at. They're generally more cost effective. But the US is better for 5-year survival rates on most types of cancer.

Reading comprehension might not be your strong suit. The parent was arguing about the effectiveness of governments.

I wholeheartedly agree healthcare in Europe is better, but not everything is better there.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com