Hacker News Reader

It's not keyless entry, it's the electronic keys used for push-to-start (which is also an unavoidable option, but it's one I like).

View on HN

illamint: the feature is sold as "comfort access keyless entry," and it allows the driver to start the engine without inserting the electronic key. (Without this feature, the default setup for BMWs is that the driver must insert the electronic key before starting the engine -- a form of two-step authentication that isn't susceptible to the attack described in the article.)

FWIW, I know about this firsthand because I bought a new BMW last year and I was adamant about not having the "keyless entry" feature -- for security reasons. The BMW salesperson acted like I was a bit crazy.

Having the comfort access feature, and having a car stolen many years ago, there's no way I would trade one of my most enjoyed features for a lower risk of car theft.

The reality is that if someone wants your car they're going to get it.

Why get rid of an awesome convenience feature for the risk of something that is a) unlikely and b) won't cost you anything (absent a small deductible) if it does happen?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com