Hacker News Reader

Comment by globular-toast | Hacker News Reader

I don't get how this would do away with the need for some kind of ETL. Most apps use highly normalised schemas that are completely unsuitable for analytical users. Not to mention you wouldn't want to couple your app schema to your warehouse schema. Am I missing something? How would this replace traditional data warehousing?

View on HN

Good point. For more complex scenarios, people would still be able to implement, for example, a Medallion Architecture to progressively improve data quality and structure. Because it is Postgres- and Iceberg-compatible (db and data), it's possible to bring more other advanced data tools when it's needed to perform data transformation and movement. Currently, we see it as a Postgres read replica for analytics. But it's easy to imagine that in the future it could be used as a standalone OSS database on top of a data lakehouse with an open format in S3.

Cool, I can definitely see this smoothing the path towards a full DW solution, assuming that is ever needed. Could you see it working with something like dbt, say doing transformations in a dedicated pg database then serving the transformed data to users via the read replica?

Out of interest, do you know any good resources covering the current state of data engineering? I find the area quite impenetrable compared to software engineering. Almost like much of it is trade secrets and passed down knowledge and none of it written down.

Our plan is to make BemiDB work with dbt by leveraging the Postgres-compatibility (supported dbt adapters https://docs.getdbt.com/docs/trusted-adapters). So it should be possible to transform data from Postgres or directly from BemiDB, which may actually perform better.

You're right, the data engineering world is complex, constantly evolving, and has many various solutions. I'd also like to know about any good resources that people use :)

For us, we mostly talked to many potential users asking about their data setups and challenges, and had many conversations with friends and experts in this field. I also read a few weekly newsletters, substracks, and follow people in this space on X (many recently started posting on Bluesky). For a deeper research, reading docs and specs, experimenting, watching talks, listening to podcasts, reading subreddits, etc.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com