Hacker News Reader

Comment by 8f2ab37a-ed6c | Hacker News Reader

Too bad it's still sluggish for latest tech game dev with engines like UE :( It'd be great to ditch the Windows ecosystem, at least at dev time.

View on HN

Game performance is often GPU bound, not CPU bound.

It depends on the game. If there are a lot of game simulation calculations to do for every frame, then you're going to be CPU constrained. If it's a storybook that you're walking through and every pixel is raytraced using tons of 8000x8000 texture maps, then it's going to be GPU constrained.

Most games are combinations of the two, and so some people are going to be CPU limited and some people are going to be GPU limited. For games I play, I'm often CPU limited; I can set the graphics to low at 1280 x 720, or ultra at 3840 x 2160 and get the same FPS. That's CPU limiting.

I recently swapped out my AMD 3800X with a 5900X as an alternative to a full platform upgrade. I got it mostly for non-gaming workloads, however I do enjoy games.

Paired with my aging but still chugging 2080Ti, the max framerates in games I play did not significantly increase.

However I did get a significant improvement in 99-percentile framerate, and the games feel much smoother. YMMV, but it surprised me a bit.

> If there are a lot of game simulation calculations

Why not move at least some of that into the GPU as well? Lots of different branchy code paths for the in-game objects?

Latency of communication with GPU is too large, and GPUs suck at things CPUs are good at.

Wouldn’t the latency be because of no shared memory and game context data having to go over the PCIe bus?

GPUs suck at branchy code, but is that the case with this simulation data? I can see why it’d suck for NPC simulation, but not physics.

1. parent is talking about Unreal Editor, not playing games

2. yes, different pieces of software have different bottlenecks under different configurations... what is the point of a comment like this?

Even if it’s a relatively niche tool, if that’s the tool of your job depends on then that’s the thing that gates if you can use the computer.

Do you have a source? My experience is the opposite is often true

It's called Cyberpunk 2077

Good news! It's coming to Apple Silicon next year...

https://www.cyberpunk.net/en/news/50947/just-announced-cyber...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com