Hacker News Reader

Comment by alpaca128 | Hacker News Reader

I think all those targeted ad algorithms are effectively just really dumb. Whenever you look through the comments of a YT video criticizing a product/company you are almost guaranteed to find a dozen comments saying they got an ad from that company when the video started.

But then again, what are they supposed to do when practically every corner on the internet only mentions John Deere in a negative context.

View on HN

We have information that you just bought an air fryer, DO YOU WANT TO BUY 10 MORE AIR FRYERS?

People may be even more likely to click on those ads if it will cost John Deere money.

Which are costs that John Deere will ultimately pass on to the consumer.

The point is that the ad recommendation models don’t know why people are clicking the ads, they just know people click on the ads.

> all those targeted ad algorithms are effectively just really dumb.

They are. I've had a gmail account for almost 20 years. Hell, I worked for Google for 10 years. They know who I am. They've seen me search the internet and watch YT videos for effectively eons. Yet the YT ad targeting algorithm is so stupid that it apparently doesn't know that I'm male. I get pre-roll ads for feminine hygiene products and bras all the time.

BTW, ad gods: please don't make it smarter. I don't want ads. When I start to see ads, I block them. If I can't block them, I will just use the product less. How do you not know this? Or maybe that's by design...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com