Since the server owner insists on allowing non-steam accounts (pirated copies) to connect we can't rely on SteamID bans, similarly to GUID in Unreal. It's a bit trickier to change the spoofed ID as I assume it's buried deep in the game install somewhere obscure, but still possible. It's actually a very popular game in northern Africa, the former Baltic states and surrounding areas as well as north and west Asia: without these players the server would be a ghost town.
Anyway, our approach is twofold carrot and stick style: Steam players get near instant reloads and immunity to some of the more "enthusiastic" automodding/kick features: so for the price of a handful of VPN keys you can get a legitimate, allowed advantage over most of the server population as well as reserved username and "VIP" tag, plus you now own the game. Seems a great way to do it, as it's available to anyone instantly for that one time fee (which goes direct to the game dev), or for free by playing at least 1 game a week for 5 weeks, then contacting the mod team on social media.
The other side to that (the stick), is that rather than simply kick/ban the player we usually take some time to have fun annoying them, to show them they're really not welcome, and make them actively not want to come back.
Disarming them then giving F tier weapons, a few random teleports out of bounds or stuck in the floor, repeat amx_rocket to turn them into a firework, amx_drug to max out FOV and add "drunk" effect, and ofc a bit of teasing about what a lowskill looser you must be to have fun while AI plays the game for you.
There's also "illegal" amx plugins and commands, which are generally frowned upon and extremely abusable, but quite useful in these situations. My favorite (which most of the "illegal plugins" are based around) is amx_exec which essentially gives admins direct access to any client's in-game console, to run any command or set any setting!
It's actually kind of terrifying that exists. For example this set of commands sets network baudrate to 1000 (that'll be fun for the cheater until they notice), changes name, wipes all keybinds, then binds the default chat key to close the game, while setting max FPS low enough to be bothersome without being obvious! There are pre-built macros that do far worse to your settings too: although easily fixable by deleting to restore defaults, would be very frustrating if you hadn't backed up your config files.
amx_exec cheatername "rate 1000" amx_exec cheatername "name iCaNtAiM" amx_exec cheatername "unbind all" amx_exec cheatername "bind y quit" amx_exec cheatername "fps_max 50"
On an intriguing side note: Many servers charge for VIP advantages, to the tune of up to $20/month! At first I thought this pretty shocking, until I found out that there's some kinda shady clique where to be listed in a reasonable spot on 3rd party server browsers, a hefty fee is required, and a significant proportion of this income gets spent on "boosts".
When our server owner stopped paying for "boost" for two months, mean player count dropped from 14/32 to 3/32, and max players from a regular 28/32 on weekends, to 12/32 on a Friday night if lucky. The player count rocketed as soon as the owner started paying again... but the crazy thing is it's $180/month!
Before getting involved with moderating, I thought running a fun, deathmatch, well moderated, low ping, high performance server dedicated to remakes/remixes of the 2nd most popular map in the game would be enough to be popular/busy. But no, apparently you have to pay extortionate fees to incumbent gatekeepers, if you want your server to be visible to the majority of the playerbase!