You typically don’t even have to go to that length. This is usually supported out of the box.
No idea what problem this is trying to solve. Just seems like the user wasn’t familiar enough with how to use a NAS.
No idea what problem this is trying to solve. Just seems like the user wasn’t familiar enough with how to use a NAS.
If you're talking about how today's open source NAS software has a button for enabling NFS/SMB on a directory:
1. I built my NAS long before software like that was common. Some of my custom stuff (Eg tiered storage, storing the first few seconds of every video on flash, etc) would be a pain to migrate.
2. Some of my Windows machines are untrusted. Unlike the NAS, they have internet access. I can't give them read access to the entire NAS, but I still want to use their GPUs and CPUs to run ffmpeg on arbitrary files on the NAS.
3. I could spend a day writing more code to move files in and out of a shared directory every time I need to run ffmpeg on them. But I was hoping "FFmpeg-over-IP" would let me run a remote ffmpeg on a local file. Like calling an RPC
This has been available in Synology and QNAP devices for that long…
I used to own the tape library that is the Disney Vault. A common pattern for transcoding is to have a watched folder. Drop files you need transcoded in, get files you want in a diff directory when finished.
Neither the OP nor I are talking about offline transcoding.
There’s a pretty well understood concept of what a NAS is; this isn’t a complicated philosophical problem.
A very common workflow in motion picture production is to use NAS for storage on a fast network, mount the SMB share, have a script/tool/app that monitors the ingest directory and writes to an output dir.
FWIW the key differentiator between a NAS and other types of network storage is the protocols they use.
If files is the main primitive, it’s a NAS; it’s its blocks it’s considered a SAN.
Sometimes SANs have NAS “heads” for clients that want file access or a block level storage device.
It would be helpful to understand your specific use cases in more detail, particularly for batch transcoding (my understanding is that this solution is not about stream transcoding).