Hacker News Reader

Comment by superfist | Hacker News Reader

Yes, P/Invoke should work, especially when you are targeting a single platform. However, for multiple platforms, there might be some unexpected obstacles I am not aware of.

View on HN

The answer to this is to map the RID to the argument passed to Zig. Or just build on a target platform as an alternative, if possible. WASM is not a solution and would not work properly. It is the last resort effort in language with inferior interop capabilities.

I'm just putting a disclaimer that using WASM is a very wrong kind of suggestion, would likely not work the way you expect it to (you would have to use WASM for .NET too which is in many places experimental and is a huge performance killer) and no one does it - there are appropriate ways to target multiple platforms in a solution that splits logic between .NET and C/C++/Rust/Zig/Swift/etc., especially that Zig offers nice cross-compilation toolchain. Mind you, the use case for this is accessing language-specific libraries and for performance the solution really is writing faster C# instead.

It depends on the integration use case. For example, if I were writing a plugin system for my C# app, safety would take precedence over performance, and using WASM modules would make more sense. If I had some performance-critical code in Zig, then P/Invoke would be the way to go. However, in most cases, it's better to avoid P/Invoke, as C# is already a very performant language.

IMHO the advantage of zig isn’t performance but generating a minimal library that exports C headers, making it simple to integrate in any language. My use case is a custom document editor in zig, with a “bring your own renderer” approach”. It integrates in a C# desktop app, as a base for something like a modern RichEditBox (just in spirit - not RTF based, with way more advanced features).

I want the editor to be usable in other GUI stacks, a C-compatible library is the only approach that makes sense here

How it will work if you don't know target platforms in advance? Will you compile zig module for every possible native target you know? Is sorce code public or only compiled library? WASM is universal solution, compile once run it everywhere. There is a reson why Microsoft Flight Simultor choosed WASM modules for plugin system.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com