Hacker News Reader

Hence their qualifier “rarity.”

But it’s not that rare in non-obese people, I think is the point. Obesity is certainly a risk factor.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5181619/

When I arrived at the sleep clinic with a BMI of 22, the first thing they told me was: there are lots of people with sleep apnea who have a healthy weight, including children.

The notion that sleep apnea is generally caused by weight needs to die. People also conveniently forget that being woken up multiple times every hour causes weight gain, so often times being overweight is the consequence of sleep apnea rather than the cause.

Thanks, I'm usually the one who has to get on their soapbox to say this. I'm glad I'm not the only one anymore :-)

What's crazy is all the downvoting. Why are people so invested in this idea that BMI is the primary/sole cause of OSA? It's literally killing people and the science is pretty conclusive. It should be one of those screens you take at certain milestone ages like colonoscopies.

People are ignorant about conditions they don't have and they want to believe that it won't affect them.

I started noticing clear symptoms of OSA when my BMI was less than 20 and my VO2Max was around 51. That is to say, I was leaner and fitter than most.

I completely agree that they should screen folks routinely.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com