Hacker News Reader

Comment by frankjr | Hacker News Reader

> I was under the impression that OpenRC and systemd support similar parallel service startup features

It's not enabled by default in OpenRC because it's not stable.

> WARNING: whilst we have improved parallel, it can still potentially lock the boot process. Don't file bugs about this unless you can supply patches that fix it without breaking other things!

https://github.com/OpenRC/openrc/blob/ea310b2e580a25038f9592...

View on HN

I'm amazed projects like that are still active.

This isn't a case where systemd is ahead of the curve, every other OS also starts services in parallel.

It is a simple little startup system with some dedicated users. Open source projects don’t need huge user-counts to justify their existence. It isn’t a profit center, people just do this stuff for fun, because they enjoy tinkering, or maybe they coded it up and decided to just share it out of altruism.

Plenty don’t, e.g. BSDs. Bunch of embedded GNU/Linux systems. Etc.

I meant OSs that have consumer market share. Eg on people's desktops and phones. Nobody cares about BSDs and a bunch of embedded GNU/Linux systems

A lot of people care about BSDs and embedded Linux systems. Such as: Netflix (FreeBSD), anyone with a Linux-based router or cable/DSL modem, and so on.

That said, parallel startup is possible on those systems too. There was an out-of-tree patch for parallel rc(8) on FreeBSD some time ago, and dinit is parallel, etc. I think OpenRC should move towards making parallel startup stable and supported so that those systems can do that as well.

Alpine has market share. It's just targeting a different market space than what you're measuring.

Some Alpine linux derivatives are kinda want switch to systemd and hence the porting

> consumer market share

Almost everyone's router is an embedded Busybox/Musl/Linux system. There are billions of them running every day.

they don't use openrc though

OpenRC doesn’t have huge consumer market share, at least in the context where this sort of thing matters. For regular Linux desktops, most of the distros use SystemD.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com