It’s not memory, it happened at the time, within around 30 seconds, between me hearing the voice and her imitating it.
Good way to disqualify the opinion or experience of anyone.
Good way to disqualify the opinion or experience of anyone.
People can mix up exact details and whether two things feel the same in that amount of time, especially if they recently took drugs.
> Good way to disqualify the opinion or experience of anyone.
Look, you specifically asked for a skeptical explanation. You're right that it's not a disproof, but it does mean your experience isn't particularly convincing as an anecdote.
Can you elaborate? I tried to keep a neutral tone.
It is not remotely a stretch to attribute "I recognized this woman's voice as someone else's voice" as just a run-of-the-mill fault of perception and memory. Especially when the alternative at hand is apparently something supernatural (or, at least, new physics).
Just because our current understanding hasn’t got all the answers doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist, that’s the way I see it.
I think some things that we think of as supernatural now will have an “explanation” later. How much later I don’t know.