God this Gwern junk will never die. There's tons [0] of evidence that nicotine is addictive on its own.
> Why are nicotine pouches and vapes addictive
It's the nicotine.
[0]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=nicotine+addictive+site%3Anih.gov&...
> Why are nicotine pouches and vapes addictive
It's the nicotine.
[0]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=nicotine+addictive+site%3Anih.gov&...
Neurophysiology of Nicotine Addiction: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22454789/
Some of this can be explained by different consumptions methods. For example in lozenges, gum and patches nicotine enters the bloodstream much slower than smoking or vaping so even if you consume the same overall amount the peak is lower slowing adaption. But that couldn't explain it entirely.