Hacker News Reader

You don't just get to do human rights abuse because someone was born into poverty or conflict. [1][2][3]

In the Roman Empire if you found a child that would otherwise die you could adopt it into your household as a slave since that was certainly better. Your logic is absolutely sound if you dispute the concept of human rights entirely.

The problem is you create a permanent underclass in the country since you take literally almost all rights from them. Including by the way the right to return where they came from.

What you are saying is that slavery is not bad because they get to eat now.