Hacker News Reader

Comment by frozenlettuce | Hacker News Reader

File browsing has been a solved problem since Windows XP. I hate that Finder doesn't provide a button in its UI to go one level up (instead I have to use cmd+up). The fact that it hides the actual drives makes me think that this is all intentional to have users unlearn (or not learn, if young) how HDs work and bill for that juicy cloud storage.

View on HN

>The fact that it hides the actual drives makes me think that this is all intentional to have users unlearn (or not learn, if young) how HDs work and bill for that juicy cloud storage.

Isn't that just the standard nix filesystem view abstraction leaking into the rest of the OS? Your file system could be any number of drives (or no drives at all) mounted at arbitrary points. Showing them like they are any relevant place to start for most users seems silly. Especially given that in a modern nix OS, almost everything in the top level of `/` is useless to users.

imagine the 'most users' of Apple products trying to decipher this comment—which was essentially frozenlettuce's point.

>The fact that it hides the actual drives makes me think that this is all intentional

It definitely is intentional, and for good reason[1].

[1]: https://news.slashdot.org/story/21/09/27/2032200/students-do...

Try long clicking the window title/icon, it'll reveal the tree and you can traverse up it.

Oops, actually meant rigiht click.

Windows XP explorer didn’t even have tabs.

Also, macOS shows external drives on the Desktop and the Finder sidebar by default. The basis for your conspiracy theory is just plain false.

“The fact that [??] hides the actual drives makes me think that this is all intentional to have users unlearn (or not learn, if young) how HDs work and bill for that juicy cloud storage.”

Are you talking about Mac or Windows?

Windows has those shortcuts which backtrack only to MyPC, and they’ve done that since forever. Always infuriated me as a Mac user since I am both user and Admin to get stuck in one of these loops, when I needed to get to root.

My PC -> C:/ is the easiest method I've found.

I always find it very fursting to get back to my user folder too without being stuck inside my documents or my downloads. End up adding a shortcut to the navigation panel for it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com