"discuss and decide what is true and what is BS"?!!
Do you honestly think that truth needs to be discussed and decided? The man - as much as I dislike him and his behavior - got it right. and it isn't the first time too. Sure some of his statements might seem too outlandish at first, but many of them happen. Anyone remember this http://gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html ?
I simply cant fathom the reasoning of people who are quick to ridicule any idea that does not fit in their image of how the world works.