Hacker News Reader

Comment by earthling8118 | Hacker News Reader

And if you do these things and it doesn't solve your problems, don't feel bad about it. People really hype up the effects of working out but for some of us it doesn't change anything.

View on HN

>And if you do these things and it doesn't solve your problems, don't feel bad about it. People really hype up the effects of working out but for some of us it doesn't change anything.

Worth trying in my opinion. It has certainly made me feel better about myself. Seeing myself improve every single day in the mirror gives me hope and makes me more motivated in life. It makes me want to do the same for my career too, improve one day at a time.

The effects are quite measurable

Effects on your body or mental health? As far as I know nobody crowned sports as a magic cure for mental well-being yet.

Exercise has some huge physiological and psychological benefits [0]. It won’t immediately cure serious mental illnesses, but it definitely doesn’t hurt.

Anecdotally, my mental health is much better with a good diet and some physical exercise every week.

[0]https://cursosextensao.usp.br/pluginfile.php/834363/mod_reso...

Anecdotally mine is as well. But for me it's about enough exercise and not about making a new hobbie out of it.

I guess most people don't have enough healthy exercise, getting to the point of enough is definitely a health benefit without question.

But people here recommend going full on muscle building what seems like a shift of their issues more than anything.

I love the fact that you call out exercise in its other forms. Physical labor is… exercise. Getting out and about and doing things can be exercise. It’s not just hitting a gym. I got in my best shape by avoiding the gym. There’s so much marketing around it, everyone trying to make money, when the reality is all you need is you. Calisthenics requires no upfront purchase. Only a time commitment. Lifting weights is cool too if you have them or want to buy them. Running is great too if you’re into that (or like the resulting “runners high”). I found sports, martial arts, and getting physical in my shop is plenty enough exercise to keep me in my current size jeans for the foreseeable future.

Well actually many studies show that exercise is as good or if not more effective then drugs at treating depression.

And people are complex creatures. What works for some may not work well for others.

That’s true of diets, not exercise. Physical exercise is always measurable and always works. Whether you can do the exercise is another matter. It should be tailored to your body. It should be hard. It should hurt (in soreness, not in pain). I’ve seen people transform.

You have just listed multiple factors which can be involved in the success of an experience.

How can you claim it’s universal when from your own words it clearly is not?

I worked out to lose weight, instead I gained an unknown amount of muscle. Not exactly measurable.

Body fat is measurable.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com