Hacker News Reader

Comment by albert180 | Hacker News Reader

Well they need to wait a few more months before Apple will get their teeth kicked in, for this Bullshit Compliance by the EU Commission, and cry about handing over a sizeable chunk of their global turnover to them. Maximum fine under DSA is 10% of Global Turnover

View on HN

This will not happen. If Apple complies, it complies. They can’t blame Apple for not following a random EU directive in jurisdictions outside of the EU to begin with. They’re even different legal entities. The EU is not going to do anything about this at all and if they try: it will be blocked. I’ll check back here in 6 months to see how this aged.

I'm sure Apple is complying perfectly with the letter of the law.

Unlike the US, the EU cares more about the intention of the law than the letter of the law, from what I understand.

Not sure what “the EU” cares about.

I can tell you that the courts in the EU mainly care about the letter of the law.

Less SCOTUS-esque rollercoaster rides about intent and historical tradition, more plaintext reading of the law.

Doesn’t mean they never have to interpret if something is unclear, but the DMA is actually pretty straightforward, with here and there some language that’s open for interpretation but not pertaining to browsers.

This is the fundamental problem with laws.

I’m sure complying with the letter of the law while ignoring the spirit of it is the best strategy.

That'd be a fine the EU would be happy to receive. After the several decades of wrangling in courts. ;)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com