What do we really know (most of us) besides that we exist? Nothing. It's funny that a lot of people believe things they don't know about and most of them are judged perfectly sane :o)

The only real thing I personally believe is existence because it is impredicative. That's true logic.

The rest is hogwash until proven otherwise.

(I do believe in some fringe stuff from personal experience but that probably has a perfectly normal explanation, I just miss the data to explain it for now)

If so, let's start with the former (god) and point us not only to the proof, but also to the theorem and the underlying definitions. There are many logicians with a scientific interest in god, religion, and related concepts. Why not be open minded, after all? But we should expect more rigor in this case.

Because you cannot yet explain something, it must be God?

Usually when something appears to violate causality, that doesn't end up being the case. The unexpectedness of the result is caused by our own incomplete understanding of the physics at play. So far none of these have ended up pointing to some supernatural entity secretly judging us.