Hacker News Reader

Comment by JoshTriplett | Hacker News Reader

The Paper Mario series is commonly considered to be the successors of SMRPG: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_Mario

That said, I'd love to see a sequel to SMRPG in a 3D style, rather than always using the "paper" style for RPGs.

Not even considered, in Japan, Paper Mario is iirc called Mario Story and we have early development screenshots calling it Super Mario RPG2, denoting it as a successor to the SNES game.

It's very explicitly the successor of this game (also seen in how it kinda mimics some of the basic plot beats), it just got renamed during development.

SMRPG also marks the initiation of the comedic writing style that would later become characteristic of games like Paper Mario and later Mario RPG titles.

The Paper Mario series and the Mario and Luigi series feel nothing like Super Mario RPG. They remove too many RPG elements and feel much more linear. They aren't packed with secrets, mythos, and a vivid primary and supporting cast. There's much less mystery and intrigue, very little to go back and unlock, and scant customization.

Dealing with the disappointment of the new installments was one of the many things that ultimately weaned me off of regularly playing video games. I realized things didn't strictly get better, and that we often get sold things with just with a different coat of paint.

> and scant customization

The badge system is phenomenally customizable. Different kinds of attacks, defenses, ways to play.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com