OLPC's recipe, followed to a T, would probably work quite well. But the economics and politics of the situation mean these ideals are mutated to the point of inefficacy before the laptops reach the kids.
Technology can be plug-and-play and transformative for kids without adult supervision. Watch kids play games. The kids in OLPC deployments pick up the difficult-to-use laptop UI quickly, clicking around and finding ways to have fun with the cameras and make silly videos of their friends singing in the schoolyard when the teachers aren't looking.
But in the newly-laptopped classroom the teachers just can't help but revert back to the comfortable pattern of stepping kids through pointing and clicking all the while juggling laptops running out of battery, touchpads on the fritz, and the realities of a classroom full of children. And the teachers are not comfortable with this technology. It's another chapter in their teacher's manual they have to spend their free time to learn, however exciting and novel it is.
Get the kids anything with a thriving App Store and give them an internet connection. Set up computer clubs outside of school for structured growth and let them play.