But ISPs do not want to adopt such protocol.
That also means that every router now has to maintain a connection table to keep track of all of the pending confirmations, and to periodically check that table for expirations so it can clean it up. Maybe not that bad for a local router, but this is completely unworkable for routers handling larger parts of the internet.
And of course, anyone who has a tap into that level can trivially spoof all of the correct replies so it's still not a secure mechanism.
I do think your idea has merit though. But it’s still a long way from being a well thought-out solution.
Also, on a well-behaved networks that do not allow spoofing IP addresses, this check can be omitted.
Ideally with the token packet being larger than the initial packet, so it can easily be abused for a reflection attack... ;-)
> Also, on a well-behaved networks that do not allow spoofing IP addresses, this check can be omitted.
This is already not true for most networks, and in your case would've to be true for all intermediate networks which is just impossible.
In another post you suggest this should also allow blocking entire networks; how do you prevent abuse of that?
Your suggestion is anything but well-thought, it's a pipe dream for a perfect world, but if we'd live in one, we wouldn't have ddos attacks in the first place.
But it costs space in the routing tables and that means replacing routers earlier. It's no wonder, especially if you multiply it by thousand customers.
"block all traffic from outside from this IP" is significantly easier than "block all traffic from outside from this IP to this client". And you need to do it per ISP client, else it is ripe for abuse.
And don't forget a lot of the traffic will come from "cloud" itself.
But you should own an AS for that?
> But it costs space in the routing tables
Not implementing my proposal leaves critical infrastructure unprotected from foreign attacks. Make larger routing tables. Also, instead of blocking single IPs one can block /8 or /16 subnets.
Brilliant! Why didn’t we think of that?!? MOARE TCAMS!!!
Also, in Russia for example, there is DPI inspection and recording of all Internet traffic and if it is possible in Russia, then West can probably do 10x more. Simply adding a blacklist on routers seems like an easy task compared to DPI inspection.
They can then ignore it until their server melts (which takes care of the problem) or take honorable action if one of their customers is compromised. The S stands for service after all.
I can confirm this. I see web pages talking about redirecting traffic to scrubbing centers.
So, if my neighbour is infected and one of his devices is part of a botnet, I get blocked as well?
Null routing is available in some situations, but of course it's not very specific: hey upstreams (and maybe their upstreams), drop all packets to my specific IP. My understanding is null routing is often done via BGP, so all the things (nice and not) that come with that.
Asking for deeper packet inspection than looking at the destination is asking for router ASICs to change their programing; it's unlikely to happen. Anyway, the distributed nature of DDoS means you'd need hundreds of thousands of rules, and nobody will be willing to add that.
Null routing is effective, but of course it takes you IP offline. Often real traffic can be encouraged to move faster than attack traffic. Otherwise, the only solution is to have more input bandwidth than the attack and suck it up. Content networks are in a great position here, because they deliver a lot of traffic over symetric connections, they have a lot of spare inbound capacity.
No. Your email will go straight into trash because ISP is not interested in doing something for people who don't pay them money. Also, even if they cooperate, it will take too much time.
> Null routing is available
Null routing means complying with criminals' demand (they want the site to become inaccessible).
> it's unlikely to happen
It will very likely happen if there will be a serious attack on Western infrastructure: for example, if there will be no electricity in a large city for several days, of if hospitals across the country won't work or something like this. Then the measures will be taken. Of course, while the victims are small non-critical businesses, nobody will care.
> Otherwise, the only solution is to have more input bandwidth than the attack and suck it up. Content networks are in a great position here, because they deliver a lot of traffic over symetric connections, they have a lot of spare inbound capacity.
So until my proposal is implemented the only solution is to pay protection money to unnecessary middlemen like Cloudflare.
Say some IoT device that half of households own gets compromised and turned into a giant botnet. The news gets out and everyone throws away that device. Now they are still blocked over a threat that doesn't exist anymore... doesn't seem like a good situation for anyone.
I'd imagine that the website owners that want the attack stopped will soon want to figure out how to get traffic back since they need users to pay the bills.
Whats to stop someone from just making an app that participates in an attack when connected to public(ish) wifi networks and participating in attacks long enough to get those all shut off from major sites?
How does this stop entire ISPs from getting shut off when the attackers have managed to cycle through all the IP pools used for natting connections? (e.g. the Comcasts of the world that use cg-nat to multiplex very large numbers of people to very small numbers of IPs)?
We can add an "accept" packet that lifts the ban.
Also, how do you remove yourself from blacklist when banned by Google or Cloudflare? I guess here you use the same method.
> Say some IoT device that half of households own gets compromised and turned into a giant botnet. The news gets out and everyone throws away that device. Now they are still blocked over a threat that doesn't exist anymore... doesn't seem like a good situation for anyone.
Not my problem. Should have thought twice before buying a vulnerable device and helping criminals. As a solution they can buy a new IP address from their ISP.