"I'll take 'facile and reductive statements' for $100 please, Alex."

CO2 is demonstrably emitted as a pollutant, but it's only a fertilizer in pretty poetic sense: Plant growth is bottlenecked by other factors.

And water is essential for life, so that must mean it’s impossible to drown, right?

Funny that people who say things like this and “CO2 is only 0.04% of the air” don’t want to try injecting 0.04% of their blood volume of hydrogen cyanide and seeing if such a tiny amount of something can have an effect…

So is rape ....

https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2020/12/more-co2-in-the-a...

By that logic, so is ammonia.

Care to take a big huff off a farmer's anhydrous ammonia tank?