Hacker News Reader

Comment by seltzered_ | Hacker News Reader

Kinda wish this lawsuit also included the issue where many HP printers will not print a black and white page in situations where one has plenty of black ink but the color cartridges are empty.

View on HN

That’s likely because it’s unable to print the tracking dots[1].

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Identification_Code

According to that article, the tracking dots only apply for color printers/printouts, so they wouldn’t apply in GP’s scenario (out of color ink).

OP has a color printer...? Do you instead mean to say that tracking dots shouldn't be printed in B/W mode?

I doubt that tbh - the wikipedia article above shows Reality Winner got caught printing (presumably) black/white NSA documents because the printer was able to print the color tracking dots.

OP wanted to be able to print in B/W mode when out of color ink. Ostensibly, the tracking dots' purpose was to stop currency counterfeiting, so they were only ever added on color printers (not B/W ones).

Therefore, not being able to display the dots shouldn't be an obstacle to the printer operating in B/W mode, as it would effectively be a B/W printer in that case. The more likely explanation is simply that HP wants to sell more overpriced color ink.

Interestingly, the Reality Winner documents were actually in color: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NSA_Report_on_Russia_Spea...

So how does my b/w laser do this? :)

It doesn't, the origin of the dots is tracing counterfeit money and you can't do that with a black and white printer.

It actually uses some color for the grays. There are settings to force pure black and white but it’ll look more like a fax.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com