Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by Knee_Pain | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Knee_Pain·

[flagged]

View on HN

You have an inaccurate picture of the HN audience.

I thought the HN audience liked innovative stuff. Not the same old Windows-only proprietary circuit simulator

The HN audience isn’t homogeneous, and they don’t exclusively like “innovative stuff”. They also like learning about simply useful and interesting software. And there’s a significant portion of Windows users here.

Furthermore, submissions like this may inspire someone to create a non-proprietary front-end.

"HN is not one person" and "this might inspire someone" can justify basically anything. It's not really a good argument

The fact is that enough of the HN audience finds the submission interesting that it has been upvoted to the front page. And you are being downvoted. Which means that a significant enough portion of the audience doesn’t share your assessment.

So the rational thing to do would be to adjust your expectations regarding the spectrum of what is popular on HN.

Maybe also consider that probably most HN members each individually only find a fraction of the front-page submissions interesting.

> Why

Maybe to celebrate the page 2nd-level linked in the submitted, "30 Free Circuit Simulators Lightly Reviewed" / "Best free analog circuit simulators", where the third and last substantive paragraph is all about "This will not suit everyone but look"

https://www.designworldonline.com/best-free-analog-circuit-s...

This article seems to be writtten by someone who doesn't use circuit simulators in real life. As someone has mentioned, you need good models, but when your circuit simulator cannot simulate current sources or transistors is useless.

Maybe it's news that hackers and other technical software dev type people would like?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com