People don't actually participate in 100 different activities all the time and they are very annoyed if someone is trying to grab their attention.
Also, although there are all kind of people at the town square, those who scream "if evolution is real why the monkey in the forest don't become human" are nuisance for those who already went through the evolution theory and know why monkeys are not becoming human still.
Therefore, the whole concept of discovering different kind of people and being exposed to different ideas is not analogous to a feed with christian fundamentalist and atheists screaming to each other because people have different knowledge levels and some are more up to speed than the others on different topics.
A true town square are the forums where you can actually browse topics and participate in those who are at your level. Reddit is a closer analogy to a town square than Twitter.