1. https://www.usgs.gov/mission-areas/water-resources/science/l...
So if it isn’t our underground reservoirs, maybe it’s, I dunno, above-ground reservoirs?
For the remaining 20%, it gets used by industry (10%) and residences (10%), where some of it goes back into the ground because it's watering the grass, but the bulk of it gets sent down the drain, in some cases to be reclaimed and reused (toilet to tap sewage systems) or sent to drain the the ocean.
For other states the ratios are different, but California in particular is egregious in agriculture's abuse of the aquifers.
Some travels back down through the soil, most either evaporates or is taken up by plant matter, sweat out, goes to meat, etc. - which results in movement of the water mass to elsewhere on the planet.
Groundwater naturally is somewhat steady state. You get rain, it filters through and then there is spring or something somewhere and goes back to cycle in river or evaporation. Part of the cycle.
Now if you remove more water than exit through the natural processes you move it out from groundwater table. Thus creating imbalance and changing the steady state.