Hacker News Reader

Comment by amelius | Hacker News Reader

As opposed to being honest and trying to understand the paper, and if you fail then writing in your review that it is too difficult to understand?

View on HN

Unfortunately both my mental health conditions and time constraints are such that I don't have the ability to spend time to understand the paper right now

Then don’t review it. I spend months or years writing papers. A voluntary reviewer who won’t bother reading is not helpful.

But then the journal may flag me as being unreliable. No thanks... I think I will just put in the shitty review

In Germany recently a medical specialist was jailed for 7.5 years for delivering wrong all clear results when reviewing skin cancer samples. He was aware he was not mentally healthy and was mot able to do his job.

Please get help instead of playing pretend and barreling through. People will get hurt by wrong expert statements. You fear for career while at the same time putting the career of another at risk.

People get respect for saying ‚no‘.

I'm a quantum physicist, not a medical doctor.

But you are unreliable. Selfish people like you makes the world a worse place.

Sorry but my career is an astronomically higher priority than any ideology of good peer review practises, and also an astronomically higher priority than "making the world a better place"

Oh now I remember your post about your depressing post doc. Why do you care about getting marked as an unreliable reviewer if you are not staying in academia after the post doc? If its for your cv you can just write reviewer for what ever journal you want. Nobody is gonna check it.

You have to learn to say no to reviewing tasks that you can't do.

That's not how having a job works

I get that you're stressed out and overworked, and I don't mean to add to it, but you seem to be confused between having an academic career and killing yourself. You're doing authors, editors, and yourself no favors by taking on load that you can't handle.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com